SlotForum banner

Pickup Braid Selection, Preparation and Maintenance

7.9K views 15 replies 10 participants last post by  RichD  
#1 ·
Pickup Braid selection, preparation and maintenance

I did a post race Inspection of a car on my setup plate recently.
I observed just how little of the braid contacts the rail surface.
A while back I did some experimentation with braid prep and have settled on a braid, a prep method and a maintenance regimen.

However, I'm writing this just to collect my thoughts on this subject, garner other racers opinions and explore other options.

Let's start with what the braid is for (A to D below)

A- Maintain contact with the track rail (so that the inputs from the controller make it to the motor)
The impacts of Poor contact are:
i) Power delivery can be compromised leading to lack of control
ii) Braking can be compromised and may even completely fail leading to catastrophic high speed DeSlots.

B- To soften the impact of the track joints and imperfections
A hard leading edge can lead to high speed straight line "W-T-F" DeSlots

C- To keep the car in the slot
The guide blade should sit as deep into the slot as possible without bottoming out
If the braid sits too high it can lift the blade up and cause in-corner DeSlots

D - maintain a friction free contact, not impeding the forward motion of the car

Configurations:
The configuration options to achieve the above:
- thickness of braid
- length of braid
- braid (cuts and bends)
- material (tinned or not?)
- additives
- selection of the guide
- trimming of the guide blade depth

Maintenance options that may also impact the above
- cleaning fluids used and frequency of use
- tools and how they are used
- the application of additives

Observation:
My current selections are based on
- lap times
- at home "non track" testing and observation
- on track observation of poor contact (sparking, car behaviour and handling)

My preferences at present:
NSR .2 mm race braid (Not tinned)
- This is a relatively soft braid but it is easily damaged by poor handling.
- Cut as long as possible without risking short circuit at a simple straight cut perpendicular to the guild blade to minimise braid breakup under use.
- Thunder Slot mk1 race guide wherever possible, Ninco RacePro as a second choice.
- Bend the front "attack ridge" of the braid over a small Allen key to soften the leading edge
- Very smooth bend from the guide exit, concave to the guide surface bending to a slightly steeper angle at the end (at the rear of the guide)
- No lubricants added
- Maintenance before every race with a toothbrush (my only braid tool) and zippo lighter fluid then single direction brushing to scrub the dirt from the braid.

Testing:
My selections and prep techniques have been built up over the last year based on "what works" with regard to reliability and results.
Are there test methods that other racers have used to Prove that there are better options other than those above?
So for example has anyone done friction testing, wear testing or resistance testing under load?

A particular interest is tinned braids.
I have one set (only) in one car (only) that do seem to have lasted longer and have run so many races that the copper is starting to show through the tinning but they remain in reasonable raceable shape 😀
I also notice that my favoured guide (thunder slot mk1) has the braid exits further apart than any other guide I have used. I wonder if this causes the braid run partially on the track surface (as opposed to the rail) and whether that is a positive or negative thing.

For clarity I have used the word "guide" to mean the whole "guide and blade" but the word "blade" just to refer to the vertical section of the guide that sits in the slot.

Feedback and options welcome.
AlanW
 
#2 · (Edited by Moderator)
Not too sure if you want to include setting the guide height in this discussion. That is important in getting the right amount of pressure on the braids, and can make quite a lot of difference to how well the pick up. If you run on more than one track it's well worth checking the rail height, it may well be different with different makes of plastic track or with routed tracks. It helps to have a set up board with the same rail height as the track you are running on, a flat set up board only represents a track where the rail is exactly flush with the track surface.
Depending on the car, ways of changing that include changing to a different thickness braid, adjusting the guide bed height with washers on top of the guide bed, changing the front axle height or the front tyre diameter.

...... if this causes the braid run partially on the track surface (as opposed to the rail) and whether that is a positive or negative thing.
The rail height matters, If the rail is high enough so the braid is clear of the track surface it's unlikely to matter much. If the rail low enough so the braid is touching the track surface it usually makes the pickup worse because the braid pressing on the track surface is taking weight off the part of the braid that's touching the rail. This is more of an issue with the conductor recessed below the track surface as it often is on routed tracks.
 
#3 · (Edited by Moderator)
Tinned braid is much harder wearing as you have noticed. But standard tinned braids are as stiff as a stiff thing.

Tinned racing braids are my favoured braid (I race digital). I use a braid (that I had specially made for me) with 0.05mm threads (half the diameter of standard braid threads) which means the braid is very similar to the now defunct SCX rally braid.

Totally agree with all your observations.

I would add that if you replace a guide and the stem (shaft) is too narrow for the hole then the guide will tend to be dragged backwards slightly which introduces a sharp leading edge to the track. I have successfully overcome this by slitting a drinking straw lengthways and using a short bit wrapped around the guide before putting in the hole. If this makes the guide stiff to rotate then trim a bit off the side of the material (so there is less around the shaft) and try again. Either that or use brass tube to create a new guide hole.

And watch scratch builds - if anything the guide hole should be angled slightly back at the top to present the braid to the rail without a leading edge.

I do add lubricant to the braid but that's because I race digital and Inox MX3 is great for spark suppression (which causes chips all sorts of problems and affects power delivery).
 
#6 ·
I have found that some brands of braid have more spring than others. You don't want to use something that takes a permanent set. Last year a fellow racer was having problems with his car. He would adjust the braids and the car would only run well for a lap or two. The track did have elevation changes and I suggested that his braids were getting compressed going into the uphill portions and did not want to spring back once the car was going downhill. Note that we run without magnets and our cars are riding on the front tires. Cars that have traction magnets often have the full weight of the front on the guide flag. We switched the car over to Slot.it tinned braids and that fixed his problem. Sometimes it is helpful to comb out the ends of the braids. I have found that using Inox can decrease your lap times, but it will only last for a minute or two.
 
#10 ·
Tinned braid is much harder wearing as you have noticed. But standard tinned braids are as stiff as a stiff thing.

Tinned racing braids are my favoured braid (I race digital). I use a braid (that I had specially made for me) with 0.05mm threads (half the diameter of standard braid threads) which means the braid is very similar to the now defunct SCX rally braid).
Mister modifier,
Getting braid made to order? I'd never considered that possibility.
Do you sell this braid per metre on eBay or something?
Alan
 
#11 ·
I'll set mine up with less of a curve at the end, and check on the setup block its not lifting the guide out of the slot.

As for cleaning either toothbrush and lighter fluid or a fibre glass pencil for cleaning electrical contacts. I find the fibre glass pencil best when the braids are starting to come apart slightly and helps remove any stray strands, but clean as well as each other.
 
#12 ·
Mister modifier,
Getting braid made to order? I'd never considered that possibility.
Do you sell this braid per metre on eBay or something?
Alan
I don't sell on eBay but I do sell through the Forum hobby traders initiative - just too busy at work to push things. But I do get a steady trickle of orders from SlotForum members for SureChange guides, urethane tyres, ferrite men and braid.

PM me if you want to know more
 
#15 ·
Any one got thoughts on an additive/cleaner/conditioner?

I have used Voodoo juice by slick 7 and Bobbys Braid juice by Bobby, I guess.
Munter,
I'm a recent convert to "INOX" as a braid treatment.
When applied sparingly (very sparingly, less than a single drop) it seems to add to the "surge" when a car is accelerated hard and appears to Improve braking effectiveness and reliability.
How the INOX is doing this I can only guess. It may just be a perception and not a real measureable effect.
Oddly, when the braid starts to get dirty and is scrubbed off with zippo and a toothbrush, the effect remains.

I'm going to have to find a way to measure this effect and do some testing.
I'll post any concrete findings in this thread at a later date
AlanW
 
#16 ·
The benefits of Inox are real, they do not always last too long however. Inox comes from Australia and I believe that it is mostly lanolin. I clean my car's braids with contact cleaner, lighter fluid also works well. Just before a race I apply a drop of Inox to each braid and that lowers my lap times by a measurable amount for a few minutes. As a scientist I like to know why things work, in the case of Inox it can act as a lubricant and the reduced friction between the car's braids and the track rails must help to lower your lap times. Inox also seems to promote better electrical contact. If you put some Inox on your car's braids and run it around the track it will help to condition the rails/braid/copper tape. I suggest that you get some Inox and try it yourself. Inox has a rather haphazard distribution system, I have ordered it through Amazon and now a fellow racer that runs an online business carries it.